Bandeath could host a hyperscale campus, and the plans should keep that door open. But leading with one would probably cost the scheme its planning consent, its grid connection and its community support. The answer is to build 49 MW first, on a masterplan that can grow.
What suits Bandeath to a larger campus
- No housing at the lower end of the estate
- River and minewater cooling without evaporative water use
- Existing brownfield industrial land, not a greenfield site
- Close to Scotland’s main north–south transmission corridor
What stands in the way
| Issue | At 49 MW | At 150–300 MW |
|---|---|---|
| Grid | Probably connects to the local network | Needs a transmission connection, competing with the 300 MW Larbert scheme |
| Planning | Decided by the Council | Notified to Ministers, with a mandatory environmental impact assessment |
| Flood plain | About 15 acres on the highest ground | 40–100+ acres, pushing onto lower land |
| Land | Probably within the Council’s holding | Probably needs a neighbouring private plot as well |
| Heat | Heat output roughly matches what the villages need | Far more heat than local homes could use |
| Politics | A community energy and heat project | Organised opposition from day one |
What a larger campus would be worth
At 300 MW the same formula would give a community fund of about £7.5m a year and Council ground rent of about £4.5m a year. That prize is real, so the recommendation is to phase it:
- Phase 1, 2027–2031: a 49 MW campus with a heat network for Throsk and Fallin, proving the community model.
- Phase 2, after 2031: expansion to 150 MW or more, subject to a grid offer, national guidance and community support.
The lease and legal agreement should reserve the expansion land and fix the community-benefit rate per MW in advance, so every extra megawatt pays the villages automatically.