Community Benefit Fund

At 49 MW, the Bandeath Community Benefit Fund would pay about £1.225m a year, index-linked: around £30m over 25 years in today’s money. It would be shared Throsk 50%, Fallin 40% and Cowie 10%, and run by the communities themselves.

Who benefits and why

VillageShareReason
Throsk50%The host community. It sits beside the estate and lives with construction traffic on the A905, the build and the permanent neighbour. First on the heat network.
Fallin40%The closest village and the main source of local workers. Phase 2 of the heat network, about 2.5 km away, with links to the Polmaise minewater.
Cowie10%Further away. The main impact is likely to be visual: views of the buildings across the carse.

How much each village receives

£ a year (index-linked)ThroskFallinCowieTotal
25 MW312,500250,00062,500625,000
49 MW (recommended)612,500490,000122,5001,225,000
150 MW (later phase)1,875,0001,500,000375,0003,750,000
Construction-phase advance (about 3 years)125,000100,00025,000250,000

The base rate of £25,000 per MW a year is about four times the level recommended for onshore wind farms, and about a third of what has been promised for the Lanarkshire AI Growth Zone. The proposal also asks for the fund to rise to 3% of the campus’s gross revenue where that is higher. See A Fair Share of the Profits.

What each village could spend it on

These are suggestions only. Each village would set its own priorities through a five-year village plan.

Throsk

  • Annual energy-bill credit for every household
  • Free heat-network connections
  • Investment in Throsk Hub, paths, play space and lighting
  • Flood-resilience works
  • A legacy endowment so the benefit outlasts the data centre

Fallin

  • Free heat-network connections and insulation for low-income homes
  • Apprenticeships and college bursaries
  • Match funding for minewater and community energy projects
  • Grants for clubs, the gala and community buildings

Cowie

  • Landscaping, tree planting and screening
  • Community grants
  • Skills bursaries
  • Contributions to local facilities

How it would be run

  • One trust, three village panels. The Bandeath Community Benefit Trust, a Scottish charitable incorporated organisation, would hold the agreement and the money. Each village panel would recommend how its share is spent.
  • A community-led board. Three members from Throsk, three from Fallin through Polmaise Community Council, one from Cowie through Cowie Community Council, and two independent members. A Council officer and the operator would attend as non-voting observers. The operator gets no say in spending.
  • Professional support. About 5% of each share would pay for an independent fund administrator, audit and a part-time community development officer.
  • Open and accountable. Annual public accounts and an impact report for each village, with an open meeting in each village every year.

Safeguards in the legal agreement

  1. A fixed rate per MW of grid supply, index-linked, paid quarterly from the start of construction.
  2. The 50/40/10 split fixed in the agreement, changeable only if all three village panels agree.
  3. Obligations pass automatically to any future owner or operator.
  4. Expansion pays the same rate per MW, with no renegotiation.
  5. A parent-company guarantee or bond covering at least one year’s payments.
  6. The Council can enforce payment on the trust’s behalf.

Throsk is a small village, so £612,500 a year is a very large sum per household. That is fair for the host community, but it needs strong governance, professional support and a long-term investment plan.