A Fair Share of the Profits

These are former mining villages with a proud tradition of collective action. If a developer profits from land beside them, the communities expect a fair share. The proposal asks for one that rises with the profits.

What a developer would earn

An AI campus usually has two businesses. The developer-landlord builds the building and its power and cooling, then rents the capacity. An AI computing company installs the chips and sells computing. These figures are estimates from published market rates, not from any developer’s accounts.

Measure (49 MW)Estimate
Build costabout £315m
Developer-landlord revenue a yearabout £45–£70m (central case about £60m)
Operating profit a yearabout £25–£40m (central case about £33m)
Return on costabout 10–12% a year
Value once built and letabout £470–£550m, a development profit of roughly £150–£230m

How the community share compares

Payment a year£Share of revenueShare of operating profit
Community fund (£25k per MW)1,225,0002.0%3.7%
Council ground rent735,0001.2%2.2%
Community and Council together1,960,0003.3%5.9%

Options for a fairer share

  1. A revenue-linked fund (recommended). The fund pays the greater of £25,000 per MW or 3% of the campus’s gross revenue, checked by an independent audit. At about £60m revenue that is about £1.8m a year: £900k for Throsk, £720k for Fallin and £180k for Cowie.
  2. A share of any sale. If the campus is sold, 1% of the sale price goes to a community legacy fund, about £5m on a £500m sale.
  3. A rising Council rent. A base ground rent plus a small percentage of revenue, common in commercial leases.
  4. A community stake. A right for the community trust to buy up to 5% of the campus company. Optional, because it carries real financial risk.
  5. Open books. An annual published statement of revenue, energy use and benefits paid.

Developers will argue that revenue-linked payments raise their financing costs. The answer is that Bandeath offers what is hard to find elsewhere: a willing host community, a Council landlord, a route to the grid and a ready customer for its heat. A community that shares in success is also far less likely to object.