The flood plain is the single biggest planning risk. There is a credible route through national policy, because Bandeath is an existing industrial site, but only if flood protection is designed in from the start.
The flood context
Bandeath sits inside a tidal meander of the River Forth on low-lying carse land. SEPA’s flood-risk assessment for the area covering Fallin and the villages east of Stirling identifies the interaction of river and coastal flooding as an important factor. In December 2006 the Forth flooded properties and roads in Stirling. Any design must allow for river flows and future sea-level rise.
The planning test
National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) Policy 22 supports development in a flood risk area only under specific exceptions. SEPA classes general industry, storage and distribution as least vulnerable. It classes electricity networks and digital communications infrastructure as essential infrastructure. Data centres are not listed, so the Council decides how to classify them.
| Route | Fit for Bandeath |
|---|---|
| Redevelopment of an existing site for an equal or less vulnerable use | Strongest. Bandeath is an established industrial estate, and a data centre is an industrial-type use. |
| Essential infrastructure that needs this location | Partial. Applies to the substation, battery, solar and heat-network elements. |
| Avoid the flood area | Test first: put the halls on the highest, least exposed land. |
Designing out the flood risk
- A flood risk assessment with SEPA-agreed climate-change allowances.
- Raise the platform and floor levels above the design flood level, plus a safety margin.
- No net loss of flood storage, with compensatory storage that could double as wetland habitat.
- Raise and flood-proof critical plant such as transformers, generators and batteries.
- Safe access and exit via the A905, with a flood warning and emergency plan.
- Sustainable drainage for roofs and hardstanding.
The planning route and timeline
In September 2026 the Scottish Parliament backed a pause on data centre planning decisions until national guidance is published. Applications over 50 MW must also be notified to Scottish Ministers. A 49 MW scheme stays a local decision.
- Now to May 2027. Committee approves scoping. Flood modelling and site investigations start.
- 2027. National guidance is published and the scheme is tested against it.
- 2027–28. Developer selection, a Proposal of Application Notice and at least 12 weeks of consultation.
- 2028–29. Planning application and decision.
- 2029–31. Construction and first power.
Officers should also be asked to safeguard the lower Bandeath estate for a green data centre and heat hub in the next Stirling Local Development Plan.